3d studio max 2011 vs maya 2011

http://area.autodesk.com/blogs/cory/what_s_new_in_2011 <---what's new in maya 2011
http://area.autodesk.com/blogs/ken/3ds_max_2011_announced <--- what's new in max 2011

mas madaming bago sa maya.palaging kaunti dinadagdag sa max.

ganun? ano pala ginagamit mo sir?

LadiesMan217 - parehas yung last na trabaho ko pure max lang gamit sa gaming kasi kaya napatagal din ako sa max.tsaka arki din napagaralan ko kaya max din una kong software.
pero mas prefer ko yung maya kasi sa film yung pinaka dream job ko eh at nangangarap makapasok sa hollywood. mas madami kasing kayang gawin yung maya sa madaling paraan pag dating sa film, pero kaya din naman ng max mas madali nga lang sa maya.,
totoo yung sinasabing wala sa 3d app yan kundi nasa artist.. hindi sa software, pero malaking factor pa din kung anong field yung gusto mo kaya ibabatay mo yung software na mas akma para don.eh nabanggit ko lang baka kasi may magreact na pinagkukumpara ko yung dalawa.

Max is not just for gaming, It caters to CG Films too. Both softwares are powerful in its own way. They're equally superior.

The only thing that matters is how you deliver quality outputs. Like different artists use different brushes and medium, tayo din as CG artists, kung saan tayo comfortable, doon tayo.

So the argument will change from "which 3D package is better?" to "which 3D package are you comfortable in using?"

In my experience, mas realistic ang output ko kung Maya ang gamitin kaysa Max. At saka di na kailangan ng plug-ins ang Maya, nandyan na lahat kinakailangan. Once I shift from Max to Maya, kita mo agad ang kagandahan niya. Yon nga lang kailangan mo ng kunting time to familiarize its interface kasi magkaiba ng kunti. Para siyang Mac at windows..

decsro wrote:In my experience, mas realistic ang output ko kung Maya ang gamitin kaysa Max. At saka di na kailangan ng plug-ins ang Maya, nandyan na lahat kinakailangan. Once I shift from Max to Maya, kita mo agad ang kagandahan niya. Yon nga lang kailangan mo ng kunting time to familiarize its interface kasi magkaiba ng kunti. Para siyang Mac at windows..

Sir pasensya ha in my opinion sir i totally disagree sayo .. max at maya are both the same in terms of capability, what maya can do .. max can do also.. what max can do maya can do also .. it all depends in the user, regarding sa plugins . na sina sabi mo maya also needs plugins to make the life of the user easier at again its all because of business nandyan lng yan lahat naka hidden, sa realistic naman na output again disagree ako sayo maya and max uses mentalray developed by mentalimages so same lng ang output nila again nasa user techniques . sa OS nman the new max now supports MAC (http://download.autodesk.com/us/3dsmax/documentation/3ds_Max_FAQ.pdf)so again it doesnt matter kung anong software gamitin mo as long as comfortable ka .. i've be a max and maya user i always use both and at the end of the day the output still matters .

opinion lng naman sir just to clarify it at magbigay idea sa mga members natin mapa maya,max, xsi, su , kahit ano pa dyan once u've learn the techniques you can be as good as any cg expert in the industry today.

Pasingit po mga experts.. I've read alot of discussions about this two. And I for one love's maya. And I think they are equally the same nga. Gumagamit din ako ng max. So ang masasabi ko lang na max is superior pag dating sa architecture whereas maya is for animation. Mapapansin mo tlga pag dating sa maya2012 and 3dsmax 2012. For example ang viewport 2.0 ng maya and human i.k for easier integration pag dating sa animation, and sa max naman is the new library of architectural textures and iray renderer for easier, realistic, faster rendering. But they are still capable of doing all. In my opinion kahit alin sa dalawa ang namaster mo is maganda parin, kasi these are the two leading softwares in the industry of CG. But then again, I could be wrong.

sus! weder weder lang yan.

most of you guys say pareho pareho lang tapos at the end you'll say why the other sucks

The bottomline is use what you are comfortable with.

v_wrangler wrote:sus! weder weder lang yan.

most of you guys say pareho pareho lang tapos at the end you'll say why the other sucks

The bottomline is use what you are comfortable with.

Yes na Yes ako dito, wag nyo ng pagtalunan yan...ginawa yan para sa mga user, just as long na mas marami kayong alam na software mas maganda at mas hahanapin kayo ng Client or Employer. Magaling ang pinoy eh, hindi nakukuntento sa isang nalalaman. sabi nga ni Ka Ernie Baron " Knowledge is Power"